If you're planning to move to Northeast Tennessee, Gray and Jonesborough may already be on your list of places to call home. Both offer appealing neighborhoods, convenient connections to the Tri-Cities, and their own unique character.
But how do you decide between them?
Choosing a home based only on a Saturday afternoon of touring properties can make the decision more difficult than it needs to be. One home may offer an easier commute, while another may have the setting, floor plan, or atmosphere you've always wanted.
The truth is, you're not just buying a house. You're choosing what your everyday life will look like.
Before deciding between Gray and Jonesborough, here are five tests to help you determine which area deserves a closer look.
1. Test Your Actual Daily Commute
Start with the places you need to go regularly. Is your job in Johnson City? Do you travel to Kingsport? Are your family, hobbies, or other commitments located somewhere in between?
Gray is located along the Interstate 26 corridor, making it an area worth exploring if your routine frequently takes you between Johnson City and Kingsport.
Jonesborough, on the other hand, connects to the Highway 11E corridor, which may be more convenient depending on your destination and the specific neighborhood you're considering.
However, don't assume that every Gray home offers an easier commute or that every Jonesborough property is close to downtown.
Here's the test: Start from the actual driveway of the home you're considering. Drive to your regular destination at the time you'd normally travel, then test the return trip during your usual rush hour.
Pay attention to intersections, difficult turns, alternate routes, and how comfortable you feel driving the roads after dark.
A home that looks close on a map may not always be easy to reach in real life.
2. Test Your Three-Stop Errand Loop
Convenience isn't just about getting to work. It's also about how easily you can handle your everyday errands.
Think about the three places you visit most often. Maybe it's the grocery store, pharmacy, and gym. Or perhaps it's the grocery store, your children's school, and your favorite coffee shop.
In Gray, explore the Bobby Hicks Parkway and Suncrest Drive areas to see how your potential home connects to nearby shopping and services.
In Jonesborough, explore the Highway 11E corridor and downtown. These offer different experiences, from practical everyday errands to a more relaxed downtown visit.
Ask yourself:
Can you combine your regular errands into one convenient trip?
Are you constantly backtracking?
Are entrances and exits easy to navigate?
Is your preferred grocery store close enough to make regular visits convenient?
The goal is to understand what your typical week will actually look like, not just whether a store appears nearby on Google Maps.
3. Compare the Actual Homes, Not Just the Towns
It's easy to assume one area offers more house for your money, but comparing two different properties doesn't necessarily tell you which market provides better value.
In DJ's video, he compares two similar split-foyer homes to demonstrate how different properties can offer different advantages.
The Gray example is located at 1105 Kennesaw Drive, listed at $384,900, with three bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and approximately 1,946 finished square feet.
The Jonesborough-area example is at 608 John Green Road, listed at $350,000, with three bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and approximately 2,324 finished square feet.
These are individual listing examples from October 26, 2026, not average prices or a complete comparison of the two housing markets.
When comparing homes, look beyond the kitchen and bedroom count. Consider where you'll park, how you'll bring groceries inside, where you'll do laundry, how the living spaces connect, and how much of the property you'll actually use.
A larger lot doesn't automatically mean more usable outdoor space. In Northeast Tennessee, some properties have sloped yards that require additional consideration.
Likewise, more finished square footage doesn't always mean a more functional floor plan.
The age of the home, condition, layout, and overall maintenance needs may matter more to you than the town name or asking price.
4. Understand the Maintenance That Comes With the Property
A slower pace of life sounds wonderful, but the wrong property could leave you spending your weekends doing more yard work than relaxing.
Before buying, consider the actual workload associated with the house and land.
How steep is the driveway? Who maintains it? Is the yard manageable? Does the property have gravel, asphalt, or concrete access? Will you need to hire someone to maintain the outdoor spaces?
Also, pay attention to the home's condition. A professional inspection can help identify immediate repairs and potential maintenance concerns.
During your due diligence period, verify important details such as:
Property taxes and insurance costs.
Water and sewer arrangements.
Utility providers.
Neighborhood association fees or pending assessments.
Any restrictions that may affect renovations or improvements.
If you're considering a historic-register property in Jonesborough, check with the appropriate governing authority about restrictions that could affect the changes you want to make.
Remember, a smaller property can still require maintenance, and a newer home can still have unexpected expenses.
Buy the workload you actually want. Whether you enjoy maintaining your yard, prefer hiring someone to handle it, or want as little outdoor upkeep as possible, make sure the property supports that lifestyle.
5. Experience the Atmosphere You'll Actually Use
This is where the personalities of Gray and Jonesborough can become especially important.
Jonesborough offers a recognizable historic downtown with local storefronts, restaurants, community events, and opportunities to enjoy a relaxed afternoon. If walking Main Street, visiting local businesses, or attending a local performance sounds appealing, Jonesborough deserves a spot on your scouting list.
Gray offers a different experience. Its location along Interstate 26 provides access to the surrounding Tri-Cities, while attractions like the Hands On! Discovery Center and Gray Fossil Site add to the area's appeal.
You may also want to explore neighborhoods around The Ridges and Blackthorn Club in the Jonesborough area if golf and country club amenities are important to your lifestyle.
But don't choose an area simply because it sounds appealing. Ask yourself whether you'll actually use the amenities and experiences nearby.
A downtown atmosphere may sound wonderful, but will you visit regularly? A golf community may look attractive, but is golfing part of your routine?
The best location is the one that fits the life you want to live.
Before You Make an Offer, Test Both Areas
If you're planning a scouting visit to Northeast Tennessee, start by writing down your three biggest priorities.
Choose one serious home candidate in Gray and one in Jonesborough. Visit both under similar conditions and give each property the same amount of attention.
Drive your weekday commute, complete your three-stop errand loop, walk through the home as if you already live there, and consider the maintenance involved. Spend some time enjoying the nearby activities you would realistically use.
Most importantly, identify your non-negotiables.
If your workweek consistently takes you between Johnson City and Kingsport, Gray may be one of the first areas worth exploring. If being close to a historic downtown is a major priority, look closely at Jonesborough and the specific neighborhoods that connect to it.
And if the house itself is your biggest priority, keep both areas on your list.
Find the Right Place to Call Home in Northeast Tennessee
DJ Slivka understands that choosing where to live is about more than finding a beautiful house. His family relocated to Northeast Tennessee from Nashville, and that experience helped shape the way he approaches helping others make their move.
You don't have to know which town you want to live in before starting your home search. That's something you can figure out together by understanding your budget, priorities, commute, and lifestyle.
Thinking about moving to Gray, Jonesborough, or another part of Northeast Tennessee?
Visit slivkapg.com and click the Get in Touch button to connect with DJ Slivka and the Slivka Property Group team.
Let's find a home that doesn't just look good on showing day, but makes sense for your everyday life.


